September 6


Why leadership development doesn’t work

Most leadership development is a dead-end

Put it another way, it promises a lot but generally doesn’t result in lasting organisational impact.

Why is this?

Well, let’s take a typical scenario.  Does this sound familiar?

Bob comes back from a two-day leadership training offsite with 40 other  VPs from his company.  He’s found the program engaging and interesting and is motivated to put some of the management concepts into practice.  He walks in to the office with a shiny new binder of material under his arm.

His team groan.  Not only are they slightly resentful that their manager has been on another ‘jolly’ whilst they get on with the real work, but they’re now suspicious.  What new hoops is their manager going to make them jump through now?  What’s the fad of the month?

“Don’t worry,” they whisper to each other.  “Let’s just smile and keep our heads down and his enthusiasm will burn off in a couple of weeks.”

And indeed, within a couple of weeks there’s no real sign of any changed leadership behaviour.  The team keeps doing what it’s always done, how it’s always done it.

I’ve seen this scenario many times.  And to be honest, I’ve probably been in Bob’s shoes myself.  I’ve got my fair share of dusty management course binders on my own shelf.  Fair cop.

I remember the earliest time I saw this play out. It was early in my career and a senior manager came up with a team plan called “VISTA” – which his team immediately dubbed “Virtually Impossible State To Achieve”!  It was dead-on-arrival.

The more we see this play out, the more cynical and sceptical we get about whether ‘soft skills’ can really be improved and whether any of this people-development stuff can really deeply transform an organisation.  But before we write off people development, let’s have a look at why the current way of doing things just isn’t delivering.  We’ll start to see that there is a better way.

6 reasons why most leadership development doesn’t work

Let’s break apart that scenario a little and understand the six distinct factors that tend to turn leadership development into a dead-end activity.

1. Blips

So much leader development activities are ‘blips’ … disconnected, one-off events with no follow up.

  • Attending a training course … a blip.
  • Listening to a leadership speaker … a blip.
  • Reading a book … a blip.

We have a saying that gets right to the heart of the issue. “Events inspire, journeys transform”

If leadership development continues to be structured primarily around events rather than processes, then we will increasingly be frustrated and sceptical as the gap between what is promised and what we experience continues to widen.

2. “First class / coach class”

Leadership development feels a bit like a commercial airliner.

  • Up at the front in first class sit the execs, with their comfy seats and swish leadership development retreats and personal coaching sessions.
  • At the back, in coach, you find the remaining 85% of the organisation (just trying to stop the guy in front reclining his seat and crushing their knees)
  • From time to time someone from the front of the plane wanders down to the back and explains a little bit about the menu being served at the front.  Unsurprisingly, nobody wants to know.

This exclusive approach to management training is a recipe for resentment, but more importantly it doesn’t enable a bridge to built between the execs (who typically enjoy the engagement with management concepts) and the rest of the employees (who are generally more interested with getting through their workload).

Result? A dead-end.

3. “Flashing zeros on the VHS recorder”

OK, this ages me, but if you remember the old video recorders from the 1990s, it was a running joke that it was practically impossible to set the clock on them.  Unless you had a teenager in the house, it was likely that your VHS recorder would be flashing 00:00 at you for quite some time!

Leadership development suffers from the same issue. Complexity.  Very often you need the thick ‘user manual’ to engage with the material. It’s not intuitive, not easy to remember, and virtually impossible to communicate to your team in the context of daily operational activities.

In a nutshell:  it’s too complex, it can’t be transfered, so it doesn’t change the team culture.

4. Individualism

We give people tools, tips and ideas for their own leadership but fail to create a common leadership culture where the entire leadership community shares a common understanding and can encourage, advise and challenge each other with a common frame of reference.  Instead, every leader is working from their own mental model and favourite set of tools and concepts.  Everyone is left to their own devices, and best practice is not systematically embedded into the organisational culture.

5. Words, words, words

This is related to point #1 (blips).  Most leadership development is fundamentally information transfer.  And yet, we live in the Age of Google: if more information was the solution to all our problems, we’d all be beautiful, spiritually-enlightened millionaires with incredible love lives!

Information is essential, but implementation is far more valuable.

So, we need to move our people development from a schoolroom culture to apprenticeship culture. Move from 90% information, 10% implementation to 20% information, 80% implementation. Then we’ll start to get some real results.

6. No iPods here

I remember the magic of my first iPod.  I inserted a CD into my laptop. iTunes did everything else – rip it, find the song titles and cover art, and transfer it all to the portable device.  I remember a big grin spreading over my face: was it really this easy, this integrated?

The magic of the iPod was the integration of previously disparate processes: ripping CDs, downloading tracks, entering music details, transferring to a portable device.

Whatever your view on the Apple approach (I’m a fan), they have a great track record in seamless and integrated products.

And that simplicity, that integration, drives adoption.

Back in the world of leadership development, we have personality assessments, emotional intelligence training, management skills training, change mangement frameworks, company culture assessments and programmes, conflict management techniques, etcetera. All interesting, but fragmented and disparate, with different language, terminology, and processes.

This lack of integration compounds so many of the problems we’ve discussed in this article.  It multiplies complexity, reduces transferrability, and kills adoption.


We’ve diagnosed why leadership development fails to deliver.

  • Over-reliance on one-off events (inspiration without transformation)
  • An exclusive approach, ignoring 85% of the organisation
  • Complexity, prohibiting adoption across the organisation
  • Individualism, failing to create a common approach
  • Focus on information transfer at the expend of apprenticeship
  • Disparate silos that don’t mesh together

Now, as leadership development is a big part of what Xquadrant is all about, you don’t expect me to stop there, do you?

Of course not. There is a better way. I suggest you read this article on recalibrating your leadership skills.

To avoid missing out on what the alternative formula for real leadership transformation is, I highly recommend you sign up for the Xquadrant newsletter.

Do you agree with my six-point diagnosis?  What has been your experience with leadership development programmes?  What’s worked and what’s not worked?
Please leave your contribution to the topic below.

P.S. Doors have just opened on Impact Accelerator. If you're ready to create a breakthrough in your leadership impact, grow your influence and get out of the weeds to be more strategic, this is for you. It's a group coaching experience over 5 months that will transform your ability to lead strategically and influentially. We had rave reviews when we ran it last year. Don't miss out - apply now.

PLUS, whenever you're ready, here are 4 ways we can help you multiply your impact on your people, your purpose and your profits:

  • Work with me 1:1 and your whole future will shift. I work with just a handful of 1:1 clients at any one time, so you need to be committed creating a new level of impact. It's a five-figure investment and you'll need to ready to be challenged and stretched in all kinds of ways. The results will be remarkable.  Let's start with a 15 minute chat.
  • Create a cohesive and high-performing leadership team. Our team coaching approach focuses in on the critical few shifts that will make the biggest difference to your team's performance.  We start with a quick discovery process and take it from there.
  • Surround yourself with elite CEOs. Rivendell, our CEO mastermind group, is an extraordinary group of leaders who will help you raise you own leadership game. Our first cohort was sold out. Our next intake is in about a quarter, so now is a perfect time to apply.
  • Shift your organisation's thinking.  Invite me to speak at your leadership team meeting, annual kick-off, or conference. We'll make it engaging, inspiring and thought-provoking...and yet grounded and practical.

You don't need more emails. You want the right emails.

Up-level your inbox. If you'd like more fresh, actionable insights to stretch your thinking and help you lead at a whole new level, then join the Xquadrant Insider. You'll get a weekly essay at the intersection of leadership, strategy and purpose. Several thousand senior execs can't be wrong!

Privacy assured. Unsubscribe anytime.

More from the blog

Marketing gurus recommend that if you want to get noticed, pick a fight. This seems to be the strategy adopted by Benjamin Hardy in his new book “Personality isn’t Permanent”, subtitled “break free from self limiting beliefs and rewrite your story”. The fight he picks is with personality tests (Myers Briggs / MBTI, DISC, and the [Read more…]

It’s hardly new news – but digital disruption is now top-of-mind in practically ever sector. You probably have your own favourite stats on this issue. Here are mine. 63% of industrial players and 81% of tech companies are experiencing significant disruption, or are expecting it within 12 months. (Source: Russell Reynolds Associates). Digital disruption poses an existential [Read more…]

I was speaking with the CEO of a fast-growing technology firm a couple of weeks ago. We were discussing how to build on their success by taking internal engagement, communication and alignment to a new level. “I generally recommend starting with the senior leaders,” I explained. “Because leaders define culture, and people need to see their [Read more…]